Civil vs. Criminal Asset Forfeiture
When federal investigators suspect that money, real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, or other property is connected to criminal activity, they may seek to seize those assets and permanently transfer ownership to the government. This process, known as asset forfeiture, can have significant financial consequences for individuals and businesses facing white-collar criminal investigations. Property may be targeted because prosecutors believe it represents proceeds of illegal activity or was used to facilitate an alleged offense.
However, asset forfeiture does not always require a criminal conviction. Under federal law, the government can pursue civil forfeiture directly against property, even when the property owner has not been charged with a crime. Criminal forfeiture, by contrast, generally occurs as part of a criminal prosecution and requires a conviction.
Understanding the distinction between civil and criminal asset forfeiture is important when responding to a seizure or defending against a financial crime investigation. The Law Offices of Stanley L. Friedman in Beverly Hills represents individuals and businesses facing complex white-collar criminal matters in Los Angeles, including cases involving financial fraud, money laundering, tax offenses, and government efforts to seize assets.
What Is Asset Forfeiture?
Asset forfeiture is a legal process through which the government takes ownership of property connected to certain criminal offenses. Depending on the applicable statute, forfeitable property can include money obtained through illegal activity, assets purchased with criminal proceeds, or property used to commit or facilitate an offense.
Forfeiture frequently arises in investigations involving money laundering, drug trafficking, fraud, public corruption, and other financial crimes. For example, federal authorities investigating an alleged investment fraud scheme might seek to forfeit funds deposited into accounts that prosecutors believe contain proceeds of the scheme. In a money laundering investigation, the government might target property allegedly purchased with funds derived from unlawful activity.
Seizure and forfeiture are related but distinct legal events. A seizure occurs when law enforcement takes possession or control of property. Forfeiture is the legal process through which the government seeks to establish its right to keep that property permanently. A seizure does not, by itself, establish that the property is forfeitable.
Federal law recognizes three primary forms of asset forfeiture: civil judicial forfeiture, civil administrative forfeiture, and criminal forfeiture. Each follows a different procedure and involves different legal considerations.
Civil Asset Forfeiture: Proceedings Against the Property
Civil asset forfeiture is an action brought against the property itself rather than directly against its owner. In federal proceedings, the government generally alleges that the property is subject to forfeiture because it constitutes proceeds of certain unlawful conduct or was used to facilitate an offense.
Because the action is directed against the property, civil forfeiture can proceed even when the owner has not been criminally charged or convicted. This is one of the most consequential differences between civil and criminal forfeiture. A person can face the loss of money, a vehicle, real estate, or other property through a separate civil proceeding while the government continues investigating whether that person committed a crime.
Federal civil forfeiture can take two forms: judicial and administrative.
Civil Judicial Forfeiture
Civil judicial forfeiture involves a lawsuit filed in federal court against the property. The government must identify the property and explain the legal basis for seeking its forfeiture. A person or entity with a qualifying ownership interest can file a claim challenging the government’s action.
Under 18 U.S.C. § 983(c), the government must establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the property is subject to forfeiture. This is a lower standard of proof than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard required for a criminal conviction. When the government alleges that property was used to commit or facilitate an offense, it must establish a substantial connection between the property and the alleged criminal activity.
The government does not necessarily have to prove that the property owner personally committed a crime. Instead, the civil case focuses on whether the property satisfies the statutory requirements for forfeiture and whether the owner has a valid defense.
Civil Administrative Forfeiture
Some federal agencies can pursue administrative forfeiture without first filing a civil lawsuit in federal court. This process is available for property that falls within statutory categories and value limits, subject to applicable exceptions. It can involve cash, vehicles, and other personal property.
In a civil administrative forfeiture, the government agency provides notice to people it identifies as having an interest in the property. An interested party must submit a claim within the applicable deadline to contest the forfeiture and require the matter to proceed through the appropriate judicial process.
Under federal law, notice in many nonjudicial civil forfeiture proceedings must be sent within 60 days after seizure, subject to statutory exceptions and extensions. Once a claim is properly filed, the government must either take the steps required to pursue judicial forfeiture or return the property, unless another applicable legal provision governs the situation.
Administrative forfeiture can be particularly concerning because a person who does not understand the notice or misses the filing deadline can lose property without obtaining a judicial determination of the forfeiture claim. Anyone receiving a federal forfeiture notice should have it reviewed promptly.
Criminal Asset Forfeiture: A Consequence of Conviction
Criminal forfeiture is part of a criminal prosecution against a defendant. Unlike civil forfeiture, which is directed against the property, criminal forfeiture is an action against the defendant and requires a criminal conviction for an offense that authorizes forfeiture.
The government typically includes a forfeiture allegation in the criminal indictment or information. If the defendant is convicted of an offense supporting forfeiture, prosecutors can ask the court to order the forfeiture of property connected to that offense.
Criminal forfeiture can target proceeds of criminal activity, property used to commit or facilitate certain offenses, or other assets covered by the applicable forfeiture statute. Depending on the circumstances, the court may order forfeiture of specific property, enter a money judgment, or authorize substitute assets when the original proceeds cannot be located or have become unavailable.
The government must establish the required connection between the property and the offense of conviction under the applicable forfeiture law. The criminal conviction itself must be established beyond a reasonable doubt, while the forfeiture determination generally uses a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard.
Third parties who claim an ownership interest in property subject to criminal forfeiture may have an opportunity to assert their rights through an ancillary proceeding. This process allows the court to determine whether someone other than the defendant has a legally protected interest in the property.
Civil vs. Criminal Asset Forfeiture: Key Differences
The most important difference is whether the government must obtain a criminal conviction before pursuing forfeiture. Civil forfeiture can proceed independently of a criminal prosecution, while criminal forfeiture generally depends on a conviction for an offense that authorizes the loss of property.
The parties to the proceedings are also different. Civil forfeiture is brought against the property, and people claiming an ownership interest must assert their rights through the applicable process. Criminal forfeiture is pursued against a defendant as part of the criminal case, although third parties can later seek recognition of their interests.
The burden of proof also differs. In a federal civil judicial forfeiture case, the government must prove that the property is subject to forfeiture by a preponderance of the evidence. In a criminal prosecution, the government must prove the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The separate forfeiture determination in a criminal case generally uses a preponderance standard.
These distinctions can affect how a defense should be structured. A person facing both criminal charges and a civil forfeiture action might need to defend against the underlying allegations while separately protecting ownership interests in property. A third party whose property has been seized may need to pursue a forfeiture claim even if that person is not accused of any criminal wrongdoing.
Defenses to Civil Asset Forfeiture
A person whose property is targeted for civil forfeiture may have several potential defenses. The appropriate approach depends on the applicable statute, the type of property, the government’s theory, and the person’s ownership interest.
One important defense under federal law is the innocent owner defense. Under 18 U.S.C. § 983(d), an innocent owner’s interest in property generally cannot be forfeited under a federal civil forfeiture statute. The requirements depend on when the person acquired the property.
For someone who owned the property when the alleged illegal activity occurred, the defense generally requires showing that the person did not know about the conduct or, after learning of it, took the steps reasonably expected under the circumstances to stop the property’s unlawful use. Someone who acquired an interest afterward generally must establish that they were a bona fide purchaser for value and did not know, and were reasonably without cause to believe, that the property was subject to forfeiture.
Other potential defenses may challenge whether the government has established the required connection between the property and the alleged offense. A bank account containing legitimate income, for example, should not automatically be treated as entirely forfeitable merely because some transactions are questioned. The source of the funds, the property’s use, and the government’s tracing analysis can all become important.
A defense may also examine whether the government followed the required notice and procedural rules, whether the claimant has standing to contest the forfeiture, and whether the seizure or forfeiture violates constitutional protections. The Excessive Fines Clause of the Eighth Amendment can also limit forfeitures that are grossly disproportionate to the gravity of the underlying offense. The constitutional analysis depends on the circumstances and the type of forfeiture.
Asset Forfeiture in California
California has its own asset forfeiture laws, and the applicable procedures depend on the type of alleged criminal activity and the property involved. State forfeiture laws are not identical to federal law, so the federal civil and criminal forfeiture framework should not be assumed to apply to every California seizure.
For example, California Penal Code provisions address forfeiture in certain drug-related cases, while other statutes govern forfeiture involving criminal profiteering and specified financial offenses. These laws can impose different requirements concerning the connection between property and criminal conduct, notice, court proceedings, and the rights of owners or other interested parties.
Federal and state authorities can sometimes pursue forfeiture involving the same underlying conduct. In cases where state or local agencies transfer seized property to federal authorities for federal forfeiture proceedings, the applicable federal procedures and deadlines may become important. The legal basis for the seizure, the agency pursuing forfeiture, and the statute cited in the notice must therefore be identified before determining how to challenge the government’s action.
Why Legal Representation Matters in Asset Forfeiture Cases
Asset forfeiture proceedings involve strict procedural requirements and potentially significant financial consequences. A person who receives a forfeiture notice may have a limited period to file a claim, and failing to comply with the applicable deadline can result in the loss of the right to contest the government’s action.
Legal representation is also important because forfeiture proceedings can overlap with criminal investigations. A person accused of financial fraud, tax evasion, money laundering, or another white-collar offense may face both criminal charges and an effort to seize assets. Statements or filings in one proceeding can affect the other, so the defense strategy should account for the full scope of the government’s actions.
Stanley L. Friedman brings substantial experience to these matters. As a former federal prosecutor, Judicial Law Clerk to a Federal Judge, and long-time Board-Certified Specialist in Criminal Law, he has firsthand knowledge of how federal prosecutors investigate and pursue complex financial cases. His long-standing criminal defense practice includes representing individuals and businesses in matters involving financial fraud, money laundering, healthcare fraud, tax offenses, and other white-collar allegations.
That background can be valuable when evaluating the government’s forfeiture theory, challenging the connection between property and alleged criminal conduct, asserting ownership rights, and coordinating a forfeiture defense with the defense of any underlying criminal charges.
Frequently Asked Questions About Civil and Criminal Asset Forfeiture
Can the government seize property without charging the owner with a crime?
Yes. Federal civil forfeiture proceedings can target property without a criminal conviction or even a criminal charge against its owner. The government must still satisfy the applicable statutory requirements and provide the required notice and opportunity to contest the forfeiture.
What is the difference between civil and criminal asset forfeiture?
Civil forfeiture is a proceeding against the property and can occur without a criminal conviction. Criminal forfeiture is pursued against a defendant as part of a criminal case and generally requires a conviction for an offense that authorizes forfeiture.
What is an innocent owner defense in asset forfeiture?
The federal innocent owner defense protects qualifying ownership interests when the owner did not know about the illegal conduct or took appropriate steps after learning of it. Different requirements apply to people who acquired their interests after the alleged illegal activity.
How long do I have to challenge federal asset forfeiture?
The deadline depends on the type of proceeding and how notice was provided. Federal administrative and judicial forfeiture proceedings have specific claim deadlines, which can be short. Anyone receiving a forfeiture notice should review it promptly with an attorney.
Can I get seized money or property back if I am never convicted?
Potentially, yes. Civil forfeiture does not require a criminal conviction, but the government must independently establish that the property is subject to forfeiture. A successful claim or defense can result in the return of property, depending on the facts and applicable law.
Contact The Law Offices of Stanley L. Friedman
The loss of money, real estate, business assets, or other property through forfeiture can have serious consequences, even when no criminal conviction has occurred. Whether the government is pursuing civil forfeiture, seeking criminal forfeiture as part of a prosecution, or attempting to seize assets during a federal investigation, the legal basis for its actions deserves careful examination.
The Law Offices of Stanley L. Friedman represents individuals and businesses in Los Angeles facing complex white-collar criminal investigations, prosecutions, and related asset forfeiture proceedings. With experience as a former federal prosecutor, Board Certified Specialist in Criminal Law, and long-time criminal defense attorney, Stanley L. Friedman understands the legal and strategic issues involved in challenging government efforts to take property. Contact the firm to discuss a seizure, forfeiture notice, or pending criminal investigation and learn what steps may be available to protect your interests.